Need help with skimmer, Vertex or ATB...?

[Technorch]

I'm trying to decide on my new skimmer that will be going on a 125g with 55g sump. I might be upgrading to a bigger tank in the future so i have to take that into account as well.

I have narrowed it down to just 2 options:

Option 1.- Vertex Alpha 200 Protein Skimmer

Option 2.- ATB Elegance 200 Pro

I've heard great things about the vertex and the red dragon pump that it's nearly silent. About the Elegance, I like how it has a double cone and it can be used internal and externally as well.

Any help/advice on these two?

 

[loki32687]

I use a Vertex IN180 and I love it. Downside is, it's huge. If I wasn't using a 40 breeder as a sump I wouldn't be able to use it.

 

[ceige]

+1 on the Vertex love my IN180

 

[mchartier]

I run an Alpha 170, and I love it. Dont even know that it is running unless you are looking at it, plus its low wattage. The only thing is removing the cup can be a pain, seeing it is a twist off.

 

[Technorch]

I've been thinking of getting the alpha cone 170 or the 200. I know the 170 would be perfect for my 125g but down the road if I ever upgrade to a bigger tank, I don't want to have to buy another skimmer making the 200 the best option I guess.

I've been also contemplating the the new bubble king cone...

 

[Ronnie]

I also run the Alpha 170 and love it and Bubble King Mini 160 and love it. Super silent. As for the bubble king cone looks way to much like the Alpha? Same pump same design what is the difference? I'm sure you will be happy with what ever you buy just make sure you get what you want even if it is the bubble king cone.