that is unfortunate.
I have GREAT experince with nyaquatics. i ordered from Michael 3 times. The first was not good but he gave me credit, so does every body else. the second is GREAT, he picked me 2 African Allardi clownfishes, one large and one small and now they are mated pair - both are VERY healthy as Michael described. The third time, which was before Good Friday, i bought a yellow Gigantea carpet. the carpet came in as Michael described, freaking healthy beyond words. the yellow gigantea IS/WAS the best reef animal i have ever gotton in my life as you all know how DIFFICULT and RARE it is to obtain a healthy Gigantea, let alone a yellow one. and the best part of it all is, shipped to my door priority overnight with the carpet is $115 total!!!
i can't not ask for a better carpet, Allardi clownfishes than what i have gotten from Michael. i am sorry you did not have good experience but i hope you better luck next time. if i am looking for livestock online, he will be the first place i look.
edit: i forgot that i also bought an African flame angel from Michael and the fish is very nice, and the price is sweet. overall his price is very good, IMHO.