• ******* To read about the changes to the marketplace click here

Magnesium high.

saltcrazy

Non-member
One thing I have been battling is high magnesium. I do not dose it, however, it is always above the high side on my test kits. Water changes do not bring it down. Is it even worth worrying about? Thanks -Kevin
 
What is high PPM??
What are you using for salt mix?
And what test kit?
Magnesium is really hard to raise and virtually has no effects on marine life even when it's really high.
 
around 1,500ppm. I'm using instant ocean salt mix. Red sea test kit. That's what I figured but wasn't sure. Thankyou!
 
I'm thinking that is 1500 ppm.
And that's fine. I maintained a tank for years with 1500 ppm Mg.
As a matter of fact lots of folks with nuisance Bryopsis algae will raise the Mg. to 1500 ppm+ to battle it.
So you're fine with it at that level.
 
Thanks BOB!
 
You may want to go through the test and make sure you do it step by step.
I.O. salt mix is usually quite low in MG. and almost always needs some buffering.
I use the I.O. reef crystals and it's more in line with natural reef water conditions.

Would this be the Red Sea Pro kit with alk,Mg and Cal?
 
okay I will give that salt a try. Yes it is a red sea pro kit Bob
 
reef crystals is what I use too Bob
 
What is your salinity at? And your calcium? As already mentioned, 1,500 ppm is really not that high anyways. Much better than being too low!
 
my salinity is 1.025 Marshall. Calcium is also on the high side roughly 480. I do not dose calcium and always struggled with keeping it lower.
 
I would not worry about it. I had an irritating Bryopsis problem in one of my tanks and decided to finally hit it with Kent Tech-M. I had not tested Magnesium for a couple years and found it was 1200. All of my corals, including SPS were fine. I raised the level to over 1800 and the corals had virtually no reaction. Even pouring the concentrate directly over Acropora corals had zero effect on PE. The Bryopsis was gone in 3 days and the only effect I could notice it that a few zoanthids got a bit pale but are still healthy looking. I am sure color will return eventually.
 
Thanks Richard!
 
That calcium level is just fine.
If your tank is not that big and the bio-load is small you should be fine just changing water and not dosing anything.
Just remember that most failures happen cause new folks will dose too much to control things they don't need to.
The numbers don't need to be perfect for success. They just need to be in the ball park and steady.
 
How are you measuring SG? If what you are using was a little out of calibration and reading lower than it really is, that would explain elevated Ca and mg.
 
my salinity is 1.025 Marshall. Calcium is also on the high side roughly 480. I do not dose calcium and always struggled with keeping it lower.

You are all set then. Magnesium should be roughly 3X as high as calcium, so you are right where you need to be! Although with those numbers, I suspect your salinity may be a little higher then 1.025. But either way, I would not change a thing.
 
Thanks for your input Marshall! Much appreciated!
 
I have instant ocean plastic thing, LOL. Something tells me I should have something better? Thanks_Kevin
 
@ Bob. Okay sounds good. I dose Carbonate only 40ml (24 hours) My tank is 180 gallons. -Kevin
 
I have instant ocean plastic thing, LOL. Something tells me I should have something better? Thanks_Kevin

You have a hydrometer. I suggest you have buy a refractometer along with a bottle of 35PPT calibration solution. Get an auto temp correcting (ATC) refractometer. You should be able to get one for about $50 online. Use the calibration fluid every time you check salinity.

I am betting your salinity is actually 1.027-1.028.
 
Back
Top