Hey Kevin,
You are pretty spot-on. I know a lot about this issue, and it is my career. I am not a fed, but a local scientist, not a lobbyist or a private "intellectual industry member" but I can tell you, objectively, that there was a severe need for effort reduction and re-focus in the NE fishing industry. I DO NOT like the way Lubchenco went about it. Catch shares could have been done right, they just rushed it way too much, and messed it all up and did some very unfair things in the process. Sound like Universal Healthcare? SAME SITUATION. Maybe presidents should serve one 8 year term and go on their way? I don't know the answer, but I sure know our government does not benefit from the vacuum and domination by one political party. Sometimes life is unfair, but as humans in a society we should try to make things as fair as we can. This was not the case here. Rushed, not well vetted and generally the mark of extremist politics.