Can someone tell me advantages/benefits of running a open top vs a closed top

[JTM4UG]

im deciding whether or not to keep the glass cover over my tank, can someone tell me the advantages of each type of system?

 

[JayM]

Glass top:

Advantages.....less evaporation, fewer jumpers, no splash from surface agitation, quieter

Disadvantages...less evaporation (cooling), less oxygen exchange, less light penetrates through glass, cleaning it is a PITA

 

[JTM4UG]

Im thinking I may get alot more growth from going topless. Im gonna try to it for a month and see if I like it

 

[JTM4UG]

all I have are a couple of clowns and a blenny so im not too worried about jumpers

 

[beckbrass]

I left one of the panels open on my top once and had a clown jump on top and fry under the lights. Now I have a closed canopy on top.

 

[Blueflu1]

I have a glass top on one side and I have eggcrate on the other. I get slightly less evaporation (I assume) but still get the air exchange. If you got topless, I would at least get eggcrate. You still could have a fish jump if startled or something could accidentally fall in.

 

[fishfry]

tank cover

Topless all the way. Less heat so its easier on my chiller. Easier access. And if your running MH u get that cool shimmer effect! I've only had a few jumpers over the years but at the same time they were known to be jumpers. But there is always that risk. I say if they want to get out that bad then let them go. Lol

 

[Conlius]

Don't bother with a glass cover. Either go open top or canopy. They both have advantages and disadvantages...

A well made canopy (with proper fan circulation design) will not have more heating problems. You will end up evaporating a bit more water with the air circulating over the water due to fans though.

I choose canopy for two reasons: No carpet surfing fish and lack of light spill over into the room. Glitter effects will happen in either open top or canopy if you are running MHs.